Home » Contested Estates Lawyers Penrith » Who Can Contest a Will

Who Can Contest a Will in NSW?

Understanding whether you are an eligible person

Not everyone who is disappointed with a Will can challenge it. So who can contest a Will in NSW? Only an “eligible person” can make a family provision claim. Our Penrith estate lawyers can help you work out whether you qualify and whether a claim is worth pursuing.

Hands holding a paper family – who can contest a Will in NSW

Penrith & Western Sydney

Legally reviewed by Jacinta Watkins, Partner – Wills and Estates

Mon-Fri, 9am-5pm

In person at our Penrith office, phone or video

Who can contest a Will in NSW: eligible persons

Section 57 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) lists six categories of eligible person:

  1. a person who was the spouse of the deceased at the time of death
  2. a person who was living in a de facto relationship with the deceased at the time of death
  3. a child of the deceased
  4. a former spouse of the deceased
  5. a person who was, at any particular time, wholly or partly dependent on the deceased and who is a grandchild of the deceased or was, at that time or any other time, a member of the deceased’s household
  6. a person who was living in a close personal relationship with the deceased at the time of death.
Family walking on the beach, representing eligible persons to contest a Will in NSW

Eligibility is the starting point, not the finish line. The Court must also be satisfied that adequate provision has not been made for you.

Children, stepchildren and grandchildren

Children of the deceased are eligible, including adult children and adopted children, and in some cases children of a de facto relationship. Stepchildren are not automatically eligible, but they may qualify if they were dependent on the deceased and lived in their household.

Grandchildren generally need to show they were wholly or partly dependent on the deceased at some time – for example, where a grandparent helped raise them or regularly supported them financially.

Penrith estate lawyer explaining eligibility to contest a Will

When extra factors are required

For a former spouse, a dependent grandchild or household member, or a person in a close personal relationship, section 59 requires the Court to be satisfied that there are “factors which warrant the making of the application”, having regard to all the circumstances. In practice, these applicants need to show something more about their relationship with the deceased than eligibility alone.

Every applicant must also show that the provision made for them is not adequate for their proper maintenance, education or advancement in life. Our guide to family provision claims in NSW explains what the Court considers.

Not eligible? Other options may exist

If you are not an eligible person, you may still have concerns about how an estate is being handled. You might question whether the Will is valid, or whether an executor is carrying out their duties properly. Those issues are dealt with differently, and our contested Wills and estate disputes teams in Penrith can advise you.

More contested estates guides

Contested Estates Penrith

Our Penrith team’s overview of contested estates and how we can help.

Family Provision Claims

How claims work and what the Court considers.

Time Limits

The 12-month deadline and late claims.

Defending a Claim

Guidance for executors and beneficiaries.

Notional Estate

When assets outside the Will can be included.

Costs & Mediation

Who pays, costs capping and what to expect at mediation.

Legally reviewed by Jacinta Watkins

Partner – Wills and Estates | Collaborative Estates Law Practitioner

Jacinta guides clients through family provision claims, contested probate proceedings and challenges to the validity of a Will, and is a trusted advisor to executors and administrators. Her clients describe her as thoughtful, considerate and detail-oriented – a lawyer who takes the time to get every aspect of their matter right.

Last reviewed November 2026. This page is general information about NSW law and is not legal advice. Please contact us for advice about your situation.

Jacinta Watkins, Partner – Wills and Estates at ALA Law

Frequently asked questions

Can a stepchild contest a Will in NSW?

A stepchild is not automatically an eligible person, but may be eligible if they were wholly or partly dependent on the deceased and were a member of their household.

Can a former spouse make a claim?

Yes, a former spouse is an eligible person, but they must also show factors which warrant the application – for example, where a property settlement was never finalised.

Can someone give up their right to make a claim?

Only with the Court’s approval. Under section 95 of the Succession Act, a release of rights to make a family provision claim has no effect unless the Court approves it.

Do I have to be financially struggling to make a claim?

Financial need is an important factor, but the Court considers many matters, including your relationship with the deceased, contributions you made and the size of the estate.

Have a question about an estate?