Home » Contested Estates Lawyers Penrith » Defending a Claim

Defending a Family Provision Claim

Guidance for executors and beneficiaries

Being told that someone is challenging a loved one’s Will can be upsetting, particularly while you are grieving. If you are an executor, administrator or beneficiary defending a family provision claim, our Penrith estate lawyers will guide you through your obligations and help you respond in a measured, cost-effective way.

Probate stamp – defending a family provision claim as an executor

Penrith & Western Sydney

Legally reviewed by Jacinta Watkins, Partner – Wills and Estates

Mon-Fri, 9am-5pm

In person at our Penrith office, phone or video

Your role as an executor

When a family provision claim is made, the executor or administrator is usually the defendant. Your role is to protect the estate and to assist the Court by providing full and accurate information about the estate’s assets, liabilities and the people who may have an interest in it.

The Supreme Court’s practice note for family provision proceedings requires information about other eligible persons and the estate to be provided, so the Court can consider everyone’s position fairly. Our deceased estates team regularly assists executors with the full administration of estates.

Penrith estate lawyers preparing a response to a family provision claim

An executor’s role is to administer the estate properly and put accurate information before the Court – not to take sides in a family dispute.

What executors should do when a claim is made

  • Get advice early – a lawyer can explain your duties and the options for responding.
  • Hold off on distribution – executors are generally advised not to distribute the estate within six months of death, or once they know a claim is likely.
  • Preserve estate assets – keep property insured and maintained, and keep good records.
  • Gather information – identify the estate’s assets and liabilities, and any property that may be treated as notional estate.
  • Keep beneficiaries informed – beneficiaries are entitled to understand how a claim may affect them.
ALA Law lawyer advising an executor of an estate in NSW

Beneficiaries responding to a claim

If you are a beneficiary, a successful claim may reduce what you receive. Beneficiaries may be able to put their own financial circumstances and needs before the Court, which can be relevant to how the estate is ultimately shared. Because an executor and a beneficiary may have different interests, beneficiaries sometimes need their own independent advice.

Defending a family provision claim efficiently

Family provision claims are referred to mediation at the earliest practicable time, and many settle there. The Court expects costs to be kept in proportion to the size of the estate, so a realistic early assessment of the claim is often in everyone’s interest. Where a matter cannot be resolved, our litigated estate disputes team represents executors and beneficiaries at hearing.

Learn more about costs and mediation in contested estates.

More contested estates guides

Contested Estates Penrith

Our Penrith team’s overview of contested estates and how we can help.

Family Provision Claims

How claims work and what the Court considers.

Who Can Contest a Will

The six categories of eligible person in NSW.

Time Limits

The 12-month deadline and late claims.

Notional Estate

When assets outside the Will can be included.

Costs & Mediation

Who pays, costs capping and what to expect at mediation.

Legally reviewed by Jacinta Watkins

Partner – Wills and Estates | Collaborative Estates Law Practitioner

Jacinta guides clients through family provision claims, contested probate proceedings and challenges to the validity of a Will, and is a trusted advisor to executors and administrators. Her clients describe her as thoughtful, considerate and detail-oriented – a lawyer who takes the time to get every aspect of their matter right.

Last reviewed November 2026. This page is general information about NSW law and is not legal advice. Please contact us for advice about your situation.

Jacinta Watkins, Partner – Wills and Estates at ALA Law

Frequently asked questions

Can I distribute the estate if someone says they will make a claim?

You should get legal advice first. Distributing after being told of a likely claim, or within six months of death, can expose an executor to personal risk.

Are an executor’s legal costs paid from the estate?

An executor who acts properly is generally entitled to have their reasonable costs paid from the estate, but this is ultimately a matter for the Court.

Do I have to attend mediation?

Under the Supreme Court’s practice note, parties are expected to attend mediation in person unless there are exceptional circumstances.

Can an executor also be a beneficiary?

Yes, this is common. Where those roles create a conflict, separate advice on each role may be needed.

Have a question about an estate?